The Case for Engine Competition
Congress has long been a champion of competition for major
acquisition programs and served as a watchdog of taxpayer money,
demanding accountability and mitigating risk through annual
reviews and re-competes.
Strong Performance
- There has never been an engine competition for the Joint Strike Fighter. Ever.
- Congress has funded the F136 alternate engine from GE/RR for 14 years in order to preserve competition on the largest weapon procurement program in history.
- Changing course to give a 30-year, $100 Billion, uncontested sole-source contract to Pratt & Whitney (P&W) directly contradicts the Weapon Systems Acquisition Reform Act of 2009.
Low Cost
- The GE/RR engine is on budget. In contrast, P&W is over plan by $1.9 Billion to date. At this rate, it is projected to reach $12.7 Billion in total contract overruns. This could take more than 100 aircraft out of the program and represents a serious disruption to the JSF program.
- A May 2009 Government Accountability Office (GAO) report cites a similar fighter program, the F-16, in which 21% overall cost savings were realized through competition. On the JSF, that would equate to more than $20 Billion over the life of the program. Further, according to the GAO, the GE/RR engine will pay for itself with just a 9-11% savings.
- GE/RR will hold costs by offering fixed-price contracting, consistent with the objectives of a recent White House directive and the Weapon Systems Acquisition Reform Act of 2009.
Better Service
- GE/RR has consistently received top Department of Defense contract performance evaluations. In contrast, the aviation media have reported on technical issues with the P&W engine that have been responsible for program delays.
- The GE/RR engine was specifically designed for the JSF, and is the only engine designed to grow with the aircraft. P&W has already announced a redesign1, which adds cost beyond their current $1.9 Billion overrun.
- During the last major single-engine fighter procurement program, the F-16, P&W’s safety record and maintenance costs were 2 – 3 times worse before GE entered the game. Today, GE’s alternate engine powers every combat F-16 in the active U.S. Air Force, thanks to Congressional insistence on adding competition to improve the program.
Congress has invested $2.5 Billion to fund competition for 14 years. The alternate engine is nearly complete and will deliver benefits to taxpayers and the DoD for the next 30 years.
1 - Jane's Defense Weekly (03-27-09)
Acquisition Reform Timeline
Competition leads to fixed pricing. 
About the Programs
The JSF and the F136 
Facts
The truth behind the F136. 
Public Record
Public accounts of support for the F136. 
Opinions
Influential people are talking. 